Let’s get digital (with returns)

Don’t believe the hype about seniors being unable and unwilling to wrangle with online returns processes. The complaints about RMAs are from a vocal minority.

Image caption: “photo taken from behind of a senior citizen sitting in their home office using a computer to print out a return label. the printer sits on their desk next to the computer.” Artwork by DALL-E / Courtesy OpenAI, edited by Pitney Bowes. 

 

What’s black, white, and red all over in the ecommerce world? A return policy. 

Our first BOXpoll topic of the year came to us from one of our clients, an apparel brand whose target demographic is women age 45+. The client was concerned that if they stopped providing a return label in the box and instead required customers to go online to print a label, their customers would grab their pitchfork and leave without a second glance.

When we tested that hypothesis with our trusty BOXpoll survey pool, we found that 72% of consumers and GenXers (and 80% of Baby Boomers!) don’t mind printing return labels. We’re sharing the results in hopes that other DTC ecommerce brands with similar dilemmas can breathe their own sigh of relief. 

Key takeaways:

  • More than half of all consumers have completed a Return Merchandise Authorization (RMA) before. Another quarter have not, but are familiar with the process.
  • Shoppers with household income over $100K are most familiar with the RMA process—likely because brands with higher average order values (AOVs) are more likely to use RMAs.
  • Parents, who we know buy more online than average, are also well-acquainted with the process.

Key takeaways:

  • Other than having a return label in the box with their original order—an option that’s growing increasingly rare as online retailers dial up returns friction amid higher costs and right margins—going online to print a return label is the overall most preferred option among GenXers and Baby Boomers (and consumers overall).
  • Gen Z and Millennials—many of whom don’t have or don’t want to use printers—slightly prefer a printerless QR option over going online to print a label.
  • Options where a retailer doesn’t provide a physical label are all the same to Gen Z.
  • Millennials, who are often busy juggling our responsibilities at work and caring for others at home, are the most open to QR codes, which allow them to start a return from their phone while standing in line at a drop-off location.
  • Nobody—not even Baby Boomers—wants a shipping label mailed to them. We suspect this has to do with the extra time this process adds to the wait for a refund.  
Other than having a return label in the box with their original order, going online to print a return label is the overall most preferred option among GenXers and Baby Boomers (and consumers overall).

If you had no other option...

A closer look at the demographics:

Key takeaways:

  • Many GenZers, and to a lesser degree, Millennials, remain unfamiliar/uncomfortable with printing return labels online. However, most consumers—especially Gen X and Baby Boomers—don’t mind going online to print labels. Our advice to retailers (especially with older target demos): Don’t believe the hype about seniors being unable and unwilling to wrangle with online returns processes. The complaints about RMAs are from a vocal minority.
  • Contacting customer service for a return label is much more annoying to consumers (especially if they have to wait for a label to be mailed to them) than using an RMA process to print a shipping label.  

 

BOXpoll™ by Pitney Bowes, a weekly consumer survey on current events, culture, and ecommerce logistics. Conducted by Pitney Bowes with Morning Consult // 2200 US consumers surveyed October 2022. © Copyright Pitney Bowes Inc.

Get the BOXpoll inside scoop
Pitney Bowes is surveying consumers on a wide variety of ecommerce topics each and every week, and publishing the best of our findings on pb.com every month.
Loading form content…
Get insider access to BOXpoll data.
Sign Up